Publications
2002
N. D. Ostryanina, G. P. Vlasov, T. B. Tennikova
Journal of Chromatography A, 949 (2002) 163–171
High-performance monolithic disk chromatography (HPMDC), including its affinity mode, is a very efficient method for fast separations of biological molecules of different sizes and shapes. In this paper, protein and peptide ligands, immobilized on the inner surface of thin, monolithic supports (Convective Interaction Media or CIM® disks), have been used to develop methods for fast, quantitative affinity fractionation of pools of polyclonal antibodies from blood sera of rabbits, immunized with complex protein–peptide conjugates. The combination of several disks with different affinity functionalities in the same cartridge enables the separation of different antibodies to be achieved within a few minutes. The apparent dissociation constants of affinity complexes were determined by frontal analysis. Variation of elution flow rate over a broad range does not affect the affinity separation characteristics. Indifferent synthetic peptides used as biocompatible spacers do not change the affinity properties of the ligands. The highly reproducible results of immunoaffinity HPMDC are compared with data obtained by widely used enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.
K. Pflegerl, A. Podgornik, E. Berger, A. Jungbauer
Biotechnology and Bioengineering 79 (2002) 733-740
Screening of peptide ligands for affinity chromatography usually involves incubation with the target protein in a batch system. In an additional step, peptides with fast binding kinetics have to be selected in respect to satisfactory performance under flow conditions on a support ensuring optimal three-dimensional presentation of the peptide. We have developed a rapid screening system based on peptide synthesis and screening on CIM® disks. The disk size was minimized to fit into microplates usually applied for solid-phase extraction. In combination with a vacuum manifold, semi-automated peptide synthesis and screening for binding to a target protein under simulated chromatography conditions are possible. Various analytical methods can be applied for parallel and automated determination of the quantity, integrity, or activity of the target protein in the flow through or bound to the affinity support. This system also allows parallel screening for suitable chromatographic conditions like running buffer, washing, and elution conditions.
2001
I. Mihelič, M. Krajnc, T. Koloini, A. Podgornik
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2001, 40, 3495-3501
Monolithic stationary phases are becoming more and more important in the field of liquid chromatography, because they enable extremely fast separations. Methacrylate-based monoliths are produced via a free-radical bulk polymerization of glycidyl methacrylate and ethylene dimethacrylate using a benzoyl peroxide as an initiator. Preparation of large monoliths represents a big problem because of the heat release during the polymerization, which consequently leads to the distortion of the structure. A closer investigation of the polymerization, using differential scanning calorimetry, was performed in order to determine global kinetic parameters. A multiple heating rate method, based on the work of Ozawa, Flynn, and Wall, was applied for estimation of the values of the apparent activation energy, preexponential factor, and reaction order. Global polymerization kinetics is of first order with A = 1.681 × 109 s-1 and Ea,app = 81.5 kJ/mol, where the heat of polymerization is approximately 190 J/g. In addition, the influence of air and nitrogen atmosphere on polymerization is presented.
M. Merhar, A. Podgornik, M. Barut, S. Jakša, M. Zigon, A. Štrancar
J. Liq. Chrom. & Rel. Technol., 24(16), 2429-2443 (2001)
Monoliths have already proven to be efficient chromatographic supports for the separation of various types of molecules. In this paper, the characterization of the novel reversed-phase support, CIM® RP-SDVB disk monolithic column is presented.
Using a 3 mm long RP-SDVB disk monolithic column, excellent separation of proteins within a very short time was achieved. The pressure drop observed on the column was considerably low (few bars), even at flow rates of the mobile phase up to 30 mL/min. Due to the low pressure drop, the use of high flow rates was preferred since they did not influence the quality of the gradient separation. The separation of test proteins was performed within only 14 seconds; faster separations were limited by the configuration of the HPLC system.
Furthermore, RP-SDVB disk monolithic columns were applied for fast separation of peptides. Five peptides of different lengths and composition were successfully separated in a very short time.
Finally, the preparative purification on the laboratory scale of the complex sample of oligodeoxynucleotide within a range of 1 minute demonstrates practical applicability of these columns.
R. Hahn, A. Podgornik, M. Merhar, E. Schallaun, A. Jungbauer
Anal. Chem. 2001, 73, 5126-5132
An affinity monolith with a novel immobilization strategy was developed leading to a tailored pore structure. Hereby the ligand is conjugated to one of the monomers of the polymerization mixture prior to polymerization. After the polymerization, a monolithic structure was obtained either ready to use for affinity chromatography or ready for coupling of additional ligand to further increase the binding capacity. The model ligand, a peptide directed against lysozyme, was conjugated to glycidyl methacrylate prior to the polymerization. With this conjugate, glycidyl methacrylate, and ethylene dimethacrylate, a monolith was formed and tested with lysozyme. A better ligand presentation was achieved indicated by the higher affinity constant compared to a conventional sorbent.
I. Mihelič, T. Koloini, A. Podgornik, M. Barut, A. Štrancar
Acta Chim. Slov. 2001, 48, 551-564
Monolithic stationary phases are becoming very important field of liquid chromatography. Methacrylate based CIM Convective Interaction Media® monolithic columns and are produced via radical polymerization, which results in a rigid and chemically very stable porous monolithic structure. Some characteristics of small-scale monolithic columns and an example of extremely fast separation of biomolecules are presented in the paper. However, the preparation of large and homogeneous monolithic columns represents a big problem, because the heat released during the polymerization causes distortion of the monolithic structure. A mathematical model employing the polymerization kinetics for the prediction of the temperature profiles and a comparison with the experimental results is presented with the emphasis on the conversion and the rate od the heat release profiles. Finally, the characteristics of a large-scale monolithic column are presented.
2000
R. Hahn, A. Jungbauer
Analytical Chemistry, 7.2. 2000, (4853-4858)
Monoliths are stationary phases cast as a continuous medium which are interlaced by flow channels ramified with micropores. Pulse response experiments with bovine serum albumin as a model protein were applied for testing polymethacrylate-based monoliths, resulting in peak broadening that practically was not influenced by the chromatographic velocity. An empirical model was developed to describe peak broadening, allowing a term to account for the pore convection and a term for the pore diffusion. A diffusional distance lower than 10 nm was estimated. This corresponds to values observed with monodisperse 1-μm particles. Systematic investigations by changing the response time of the detector showed that the full potential of the monoliths could not be exploited, since the currently available chromatography systems are the limiting factor regarding the speed of data acquisition and virtual peak broadening by the infinite length of the detector. Inertia of the liquid and synchronization between liquid handling and electronic control introduced an additional disturbance. At the lowest possible response time, reliable peak data could be obtained up to a velocity of 35 cm/min. The pressure drop along the continuous bed was much smaller compared to a conventionally packed bed. Different flow patterns and significantly reduced eddy vortexes may be responsible for the high specific permeability.
K. Amatschek, R. Necina, R. Hahn, E. Schallaun, H. Schwinn, D. Josić, A. Jungbauer
Journal of Separation science, 23 (2000) 47-58
FVIII is a very complex molecule of great therapeutic significance. It is purified by a sequence of chromatographic steps including immunoaffinity chromatography. A peptide affinity chromatography method has been developed using peptides derived from a combinatorial library. Spot technology using cellulose sheets has been applied for this purpose. The dual positional scanning strategy was used for identification of the amino acids in random positions. Approximately 5000 possible candidates found in the first screening round were reduced to a panel of 36. Six candidates have been selected empirically. Five peptides seem to be directed against the light chain of FVIII, one peptide seems to be directed against the heavy chain. The peptides have been immobilized on conventional beaded material and CIM polymethacrylate monoliths. Much better performance with respect to capacity and selectivity has been observed with the monolithic material. Exposure of the ligand and its ensuing accessibility are responsible for these properties.
L. G. Berruex, R. Freitag, T. B. Tennikova
Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis 24 (2000) 95–104
A novel biochromatographic principle is introduced taking the quantitative analysis of affinity interactions between antibodies and immobilized group specific ligands (protein A, G, and L) as example. The name high performance monolith affinity chromatography (HPMAC) is proposed for this technique. HPMAC uses rigid, macroporous monoliths, so-called convective interaction media (CIM™)-disks, as stationary phase. An optimized procedure is described for the covalent immobilization of the group specific affinity ligands to such disks. The binding of polyclonal bovine IgG and a recombinant human antibody (type IgG1-κ) to all affinity disks is discussed. An essential feature of HPMAC is its compatibility to unusually high mobile phase flow rates (>4 ml/min). Chromatographic experiments are thus completed within seconds without significant loss in binding capacity and retentive power. This makes HPMAC a promising tool for applications in fast process monitoring or screening. As an example for the former, the direct quantitative isolation of recombinant antibodies from serum-free culture supernatant is demonstrated.
H. LeThanh, B. Lendl
Analytica Chimica Acta 422 (2000) 63–69
A fully automated method for the rapid determination of organic acids (citric-, malic- and tartaric acid) and sugars (glucose, fructose, and sucrose) in soft drinks by sequential injection Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy is presented. A convective interaction media (CIM) disc carrying quaternary amino moieties was added as a solid phase extraction column to the flow system. Upon injection of a sample the organic acids were completely retained on the CIM disc whereas sugars passed to the flow cell. The organic acids were subsequently eluted by injection of an alkaline (pH 8.5) 1 M sodium chloride solution and recorded in their fully deprotonated form as a second flow injection peak. In both cases, the FTIR spectra corresponding to the peak maxima were selected for data evaluation. Two partial least squares models, one for sugars and the other for organic acids, were constructed based on the analysis of standards containing all six analytes. The developed method was applied to natural samples yielding results which were in good agreement with those obtained by an external reference method (enzymatic test kits). Deviations in the results were 3.4. and 4.1% for citric and malic acid and ranged from 4.7–5.1% for the sugars. The developed method is characterized by its short analysis time, experimental simplicity and its potential applications in routine analysis and process control.
L. G. Berruex, R. Freitag, T. B. Tennikova
Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis 24 (2000) 95–104
A novel biochromatographic principle is introduced taking the quantitative analysis of affinity interactions between antibodies and immobilized group specific ligands (protein A, G, and L) as example. The name high performance monolith affinity chromatography (HPMAC) is proposed for this technique. HPMAC uses rigid, macroporous monoliths, so-called convective interaction media (CIM™)-disks, as stationary phase. An optimized procedure is described for the covalent immobilization of the group specific affinity ligands to such disks. The binding of polyclonal bovine IgG and a recombinant human antibody (type IgG1-κ) to all affinity disks is discussed. An essential feature of HPMAC is its compatibility to unusually high mobile phase flow rates (>4 ml/min). Chromatographic experiments are thus completed within seconds without significant loss in binding capacity and retentive power. This makes HPMAC a promising tool for applications in fast process monitoring or screening. As an example for the former, the direct quantitative isolation of recombinant antibodies from serum-free culture supernatant is demonstrated.
1999
A. Podgornik, M. Barut, J. Jančar, A. Štrancar, T. Tennikova
Analytical Chemistry, 1999, Vol. 71, No. 15, 2986-2991
High-performance membrane chromatography (HPMC) proved to be a very efficient method for fast protein separations. Recently, it was shown to be applicable also for the isocratic chromatography of plasmid DNA conformations. However, no study about the separation of small molecules has been performed until now. In this work, we investigated the possibility of gradient and isocratic HPMC of small molecules with Convective Interaction Media disks of different chemistries and tried to explain the mechanism that enables their separation. We demonstrated that it is possible to achieve efficient separations of oligonucleotides and peptides in the ion-exchange mode as well as the separation of small hydrophobic molecules in the reversed-phase mode. It was shown that similar peak resolution can be provided in both gradient and isocratic modes.
A. Podgornik, M. Barut, J. Jančar, A. Štrancar
Journal of Chromatography A, 848 (1999) 51–60
In this work, the isocratic separation of oligonucleotides in the ion-exchange mode on thin glycidylmethacrylate–ethylenedimethacrylate (GMA–EDMA) monoliths in the form of commercially available CIM (Convective Interaction Media) disks is presented. It was found that isocratic separation occurs even on monoliths with a thickness of only 0.75 mm. Peak broadening of the components retained on the monolith is proportional to the retention time, which in turn is proportional to the thickness of the monolith. Peak height is inversely proportional to the retention time. From these results it can be concluded that the mechanism of the separation on such monoliths is similar to that in HPLC columns filled with conventional porous particles. The height equivalent to a theoretical plate of GMA–EDMA monoliths is calculated to be 18.0 μm. The capacity factor k′ depends, exponentially, on the salt concentration. The Z factor calculated from fitted equations increases linearly with the oligonucleotide’s length. It was also found that the difference between peak retention volume slightly increases with the flow-rate when the experiments are performed in the range from 0.5 to 7 ml/min. From the similarities between the isocratic separations on conventional columns and on thin GMA–EDMA monoliths it is reasonable to believe that separation based on a multiple adsorption/desorption process also occurs in thin monoliths.
D. Josić, A. Štrancar
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1999, 38, 333-342
For fast separation of biopolymers, recently developed media have become increasingly widespread. They consist either of membranes or of compact, porous disks and tubes, both called Convective Interaction Media (CIM). Separation can be carried out in every mode, e.g., ion-exchange, reversed-phase, hydrophobic-interaction, and affinity recognition. The units can be used for analytical as well as for preparative purposes. Such fast analytical units will allow separations within less than 10 s and can therefore be used for in-process analysis. The advantages and disadvantages of such analytical and preparative separations are discussed along with technical problems which have been solved.
1998
M. B. Tennikov, N. V. Gazdina, T. B. Tennikova, F. Švec
Journal of Chromatography A, 798 (1998) 55–64
The effect of porous structures of 2-mm thick diethylamine functionalized monolithic polymethacrylate discs on their chromatographic behavior in ion-exchange mode has been studied. Discs with small pores did not perform well because they exhibited high back pressure and substantial peak broadening. Discs characterized with pores larger than 1 000 nm did not provide good separations either because the time required for some protein molecules to traverse the length across the pore to reach the wall for adsorption/desorption process that is essential for the separation may be longer than their residence time within the matrix. Optimum pore size is centered at about 700 nm. Excellent separations have been achieved with these discs even at very steep gradients and high flow-rates which allow to shorten the separation times substantially.
A. Štrancar, M. Barut, A. Podgornik, P. Koselj, D. Josić, A. Buchacher
LC-GC International – October 1998, 660-670
Separation supports based on convective interaction media (CIM) allow higher throughputs and separations; faster by one order of magnitude when compared with separation materials based on conventional porous particles (1). In the future, they may well play an important role in the production and quality control of diagnostic and therapeutic products based on large biomolecules. A major advantage of CIM is their use in control procedures during production processes — an important factor in satisfying the demands of regulatory authorities, both with regard to the registration of the product as a drug, and also in controlling the process in such a manner that immediate correction is possible should the process deviate from the prescribed path. The CIM supports can easily be scaled up because the larger units are made of the same material and can be used for fast separations on the preparative level. Additionally, these supports can be used for the ‘so-called’ conjoint liquid chromatography (CLC), by combining two or more discs with different ligand groups in the same housing. Finally, owing to their low back pressures and very fast response, CIM supports can be used as biosensors or bioreactors with immobilized enzymes.
C. Kasper, L. Meringova, R. Freitag, T. Tennikova
Journal of Chromatography A, 798 (1998) 65-72
A fast affinity method for the semi-preparative isolation of recombinant Protein G from E. coli cell lysate is proposed. Rigid, macroporous affinity discs based on a glycidyl methacrylate–co-ethylene dimethacrylate polymer were used as chromatographic supports. The specific ligands (here human immunoglobulin G, hIgG) were immobilized by the one-step reaction between native epoxy groups of the polymer surface and ϵ-amino groups of the IgG molecules. No intermediate spacer was necessary to reach full biological activity of the ligand. The globular affinity ligands are located directly on the pore wall surface and are thereby freely accessible to target molecules (here Protein G) migrating with the mobile phase through the pores. It is shown that the conditions chosen for the hIgG immobilization do not involve an active site of the protein and thus do not bias the formation of the affinity complex. Chromatographically determined constants of dissociation of hIgG–Protein G affinity complexes confirm the high selectivity of this separation method. Two different aspects of the affinity separation are discussed, which differ mostly in terms of scale. In disc chromatography, high volumetric flow velocities are possible because of the small backpressure. Since in addition the mass transfer is more efficient, it becomes possible to achieve very short analysis times. The discs proposed can be used in a single-step enrichment of Protein G from lysates of non-pathogenic E. coli. Gel electrophoresis data are used to demonstrate the high degree of purity achieved for the final product.
D. Josić, H. Schwinn, A. Štrancar, A. Podgornik, M. Barut, Y. P. Lim, M. Vodopivec
Journal of Chromatography A, 803 (1998) 61–71
Different ligands with high molecular masses are immobilized on compact, porous separation units and used for affinity chromatography. In subsequent experiments different enzymes are immobilized and used for converting substrates with low and high molecular masses. Disk or tube with immobilized concanavalin A (ConA) are used as model systems for lectin affinity chromatography. The enzyme glucose oxidase is used as a standard protein to test the ConA units. Subsequently glycoproteins from plasma membranes of rat liver are separated, using units with immobilized ConA. The enzyme dipeptidyl peptidase IV, which is used as a model protein in the experiments, is enriched about 40-fold in a single step, with a yield of over 90%. The results are only slightly better than those obtained with ConA when it is immobilized on bulk supports. The important improvement lies in the reduction of separation time to only 1 h. Experiments concerning the isolation of monoclonal antibodies against clotting factor VIII (FVIII) are carried out on disks, combining anion-exchange chromatography and protein A affinity chromatography as a model for multidimensional chromatography. Both IgG (bound to the protein A disk) and accompanying proteins (bound to the anion-exchange disk) from mouse ascites fluid are retarded and eluted separately. With the immobilized enzymes invertase and glucose oxidase (GOX) the corresponding substrates with low molecular masses, saccharose and glucose, are converted. It is shown that the amount of immobilized enzyme and the concentration of the substrate are responsible for the extent of the conversion, whereas the flow-rates used in the experiments have no effect at all. The influence of immobilization chemistry was investigated with GOX. Indirect immobilization with ConA as spacer proved to be the best alternative. With trypsin, immobilized on a disk, substrates with high molecular masses are digested in flow-through. For optimal digestion the proteins have to be denatured in the buffer for sodium dodecyl sulfate–polyacrlyamide gel electrophoresis prior to application. In contrast to the conversion of substrates with low molecular masses, flow-rates play an important part in conversion of substrates with high molecular masses. With lower flow-rates a higher degree of digestion is achieved.
C. Kasper, L. Meringova, R. Freitag, T. Tennikova
Journal of Chromatography A, 798 (1998) 65-72
A fast affinity method for the semi-preparative isolation of recombinant Protein G from E. coli cell lysate is proposed. Rigid, macroporous affinity discs based on a glycidyl methacrylate–co-ethylene dimethacrylate polymer were used as chromatographic supports. The specific ligands (here human immunoglobulin G, hIgG) were immobilized by the one-step reaction between native epoxy groups of the polymer surface and ϵ-amino groups of the IgG molecules. No intermediate spacer was necessary to reach full biological activity of the ligand. The globular affinity ligands are located directly on the pore wall surface and are thereby freely accessible to target molecules (here Protein G) migrating with the mobile phase through the pores. It is shown that the conditions chosen for the hIgG immobilization do not involve an active site of the protein and thus do not bias the formation of the affinity complex. Chromatographically determined constants of dissociation of hIgG–Protein G affinity complexes confirm the high selectivity of this separation method. Two different aspects of the affinity separation are discussed, which differ mostly in terms of scale. In disc chromatography, high volumetric flow velocities are possible because of the small backpressure. Since in addition the mass transfer is more efficient, it becomes possible to achieve very short analysis times. The discs proposed can be used in a single-step enrichment of Protein G from lysates of non-pathogenic E. coli. Gel electrophoresis data are used to demonstrate the high degree of purity achieved for the final product.
1997
A. Štrancar, M. Barut, A. Podgornik, P. Koselj, H. Schwinn, P. Raspor, D. Josić
Journal of Chromatography A, 760 (1997) 117-123
Membranes as well as compact porous disks are successfully used for fast analytical separations of biopolymers. So far, technical difficulties have prevented the proper scaling-up of the processes and the use of membranes and compact disks for preparative separations in a large scale. In this paper, the use of a compact porous tube for fast preparative separations of proteins is shown as a possible solution to these problems. The units have yielded good results, in terms of performance and speed of separation. The application of compact porous tubes for the preparative isolation of clotting factor VIII from human plasma shows that this method can even be used for the separation of very sensitive biopolymers. As far as yield and purity of the isolated proteins are concerned, the method was comparable to preparative column chromatography. The period of time required for separation was five times shorter than with corresponding column chromatographic methods. Compact porous disks made of the same support material can also be used for in-process analysis in order to control the separation. The quick response, which is obtained from these units within 5 to 60 s, allows close monitoring of the purification process.